The Good Earth Publishers · Publishing Answer Desk

Ask TGEP

One place for the questions that arise while writing a book, finding a publisher, reading a contract, producing an edition, selling books, building an author career or running a publishing project.

Manuscript submissions use a separate form for TGEP's editorial consideration.

106 direct answers 12 core areas Writers · Authors · Editors · Publishers Connected to TGEP's deeper guides
Try:
Search the full answer desk below.

Begin where you are

You do not need to know the publishing term.

Choose the situation that most closely resembles yours.

I am writing a book

Ideas, structure, voice, dialogue, research, revision and completing the manuscript.

Start Here →

My manuscript is finished

Editing, formatting, synopsis, proposal, biography, query letter and submission readiness.

Prepare It →

I need a publisher or agent

Research suitable publishers, agencies, direct submissions and open windows.

Find the Route →

I have a publishing offer

Rights, royalties, fees, advances, term, territory, reversion and financial model.

Read Before Signing →

My book is being produced or sold

Typesetting, ISBN, metadata, printing, pricing, distribution, bookstores and libraries.

Production & Sales →

I run publishing projects

Acquisitions, title economics, rights, schedules, vendors, print runs, royalty statements and sales control.

Publisher's Desk →

The answer desk

Questions writers, authors and publishers actually ask

Open any question for a direct answer. Use the search above to reduce the page instantly.

No direct match was found. Try a shorter term or use the Publishing Index and Q&A Centre at the bottom of the page.

From idea to finished draft

Writing a Book

Explore the Writing Guide →
How do I start writing a book?

Begin with a clear subject, story or question and identify the reader you are writing for. Then decide the form, approximate length and a workable structure before drafting consistently.

How long should my book be?

There is no universal correct length. Genre, readership, subject and publishing route matter. A book should be long enough to fulfil its promise without carrying material that exists only to increase the word count.

Do I need an outline before I begin?

Not always. Some writers work from detailed outlines and others discover the book while drafting. Even an intuitive writer benefits from knowing the central conflict, argument or destination of the book.

How do I know whether my idea is strong enough for a book?

Test whether the idea can sustain development, conflict, research, argument or narrative movement over the intended length. Also ask who would read it and what they would receive that is not already available in the same form.

What is the difference between story and plot?

Story is what happens. Plot is the deliberate arrangement of events, causes, consequences and revelations that creates movement and meaning for the reader.

How do I improve dialogue?

Let characters speak with purpose, difference and pressure. Remove explanations that the scene already makes clear and read the dialogue aloud to hear repetition, stiffness and unnatural rhythm.

How do I choose point of view?

Choose the viewpoint that gives the book the right access to information, emotion and distance. First person offers intimacy, while third person can provide greater flexibility. Consistency matters more than fashion.

How do I revise a first draft?

Work from large problems to small ones. Review structure, missing material, repetition, character or argument first. Only after those decisions are stable should you concentrate on sentence polish, grammar and proofreading.

Before submission

Manuscript Preparation

Open Manuscript Preparation →
When is a manuscript ready to submit?

When the complete work has been revised, obvious structural problems have been addressed, the file is clean and consistent, and the synopsis, proposal or sample material accurately matches the manuscript.

What format should I use for a manuscript?

Follow the recipient's instructions first. Where no special format is stated, use a clean, readable document with consistent headings, paragraph treatment, page breaks and a conventional font.

Should I send the whole manuscript?

Only when the publisher or agent asks for it. Many submission routes request a query, synopsis and sample chapters first. Sending more than requested can work against an otherwise professional submission.

What is a synopsis?

A synopsis is a concise account of the complete story or structure, including major developments and the ending. It is not promotional copy and should not hide the resolution.

What is a nonfiction book proposal?

A proposal makes the case for the project. It normally explains the subject, intended readership, author authority, market position, chapter plan, comparable titles and sample material.

What should sample chapters contain?

Send exactly the chapters or pages requested. Unless the guidelines say otherwise, opening chapters are usually more useful than favourite passages taken from different parts of the manuscript.

Do I need an author biography?

Usually yes when the submission route asks for one. Keep it relevant to the book, your publications, expertise or professional identity rather than turning it into a complete life history.

Should tracked changes and comments remain in a submission file?

No, unless an editor specifically asks for them. A submission manuscript should normally be clean, readable and free of unresolved comments, hidden text and accidental revision marks.

Research before submission

Finding a Publisher or Agent

Find Publishers →
How do I find the right publisher?

Start with publishers that already publish books comparable in genre, subject, readership and format. Then check the publishing model, current submission status and exact route for sending material.

Do I need a literary agent?

Not always. Many large trade publishers acquire largely through agents, while numerous independent publishers accept direct submissions. The appropriate route depends on the book and the market.

How do I find a literary agent?

Research agencies and individual agents by genre, recent sales, represented authors and stated interests. Submit only through the current official route and follow each agent's instructions.

Should I pay a literary agent to represent me?

A conventional literary agent normally earns commission when the author earns. Significant upfront representation, reading or placement charges require careful scrutiny.

Why was my manuscript rejected?

Rejection can reflect list fit, timing, market position, editorial capacity, sales expectations or manuscript quality. One rejection proves little. Repeated similar responses may indicate that the manuscript or submission approach needs reassessment.

How many publishers should I submit to?

There is no universal number. Build a researched list and submit according to each publisher's policy on simultaneous submissions. Quality of fit matters more than volume.

How long should I wait for a response?

Use the response period stated by the publisher or agency. If none is given, keep accurate records and avoid repeated follow-ups within an obviously unreasonable period.

What should I put in a query letter?

Usually the title, genre, word count, completion status, concise premise, relevant author background and a genuine reason for approaching that recipient.

Can I submit directly to a publisher if I have an agent?

Only in accordance with your agency agreement and the agent's advice. Representation agreements can give the agent responsibility for specified submissions and rights.

How do I know whether a publisher is genuine?

Examine its published books, editorial quality, business model, contracts, fees, distribution claims, rights terms and official contact information. Verify claims rather than relying on a polished website alone.

Who pays, who controls, who carries risk

Publishing Models

Compare Publishing Models →
What is traditional publishing?

The publisher selects the work, bears the agreed publication costs and normally pays the author through royalties and sometimes an advance. The publisher takes commercial risk in return for licensed publishing rights.

What is hybrid publishing?

Hybrid publishing combines author investment with professional publishing activity. Quality, selection standards, rights, distribution and financial transparency vary widely, so the agreement must be examined carefully.

What is self-publishing?

The author acts as publisher or hires specialists directly. The author controls the project and carries responsibility for editing, production, metadata, distribution, marketing, costs and compliance.

What is an independent publisher?

An independent publisher is not owned by one of the major publishing groups. Independent presses vary in size, funding model, genre, territory and whether they accept direct submissions.

Is paying a publisher always a scam?

No. Author-funded and hybrid arrangements exist legitimately. The critical questions are whether the model is disclosed honestly, costs are clear, rights are proportionate and promised services can be verified.

Which publishing route is best?

There is no universal best route. Compare your objectives, budget, desired control, timetable, rights priorities, market access and willingness to manage the work yourself.

Can a self-published book later be traditionally published?

Yes, but it is not automatic. A publisher may consider a previously self-published work if rights are available and the project presents sufficient editorial or commercial interest.

Can I use more than one publishing model for different books?

Yes. Authors may use different routes for different projects, territories or formats, provided existing contracts and rights grants permit it.

Strengthen the manuscript in the right order

Editing

Explore Editing →
What is developmental editing?

Developmental editing addresses the large architecture of the book: structure, argument, plot, pacing, character, point of view, chapter order, gaps and overall effectiveness.

What is line editing?

Line editing improves the way the prose works at sentence and paragraph level: clarity, rhythm, tone, repetition, emphasis, transitions and voice.

What is copyediting?

Copyediting corrects grammar, usage, punctuation, spelling, consistency, factual details and style after major structural decisions are stable.

What is proofreading?

Proofreading is the final text check after editing and usually after typesetting. It catches typographical errors, formatting problems and residual inconsistencies rather than redesigning the book.

Do I need all four editing stages?

Not every manuscript requires the same intervention. The condition of the work and the publishing route determine what is necessary. What matters is not skipping a major structural problem and trying to solve it with proofreading.

Should I hire an editor before submitting to a publisher?

A clean, well-revised manuscript is essential. Professional editing can help, but it is not a guarantee of acceptance and should not be purchased merely because someone promises publication.

What is an editorial assessment?

An editorial assessment is a diagnostic review of the manuscript's strengths, weaknesses, readiness and development priorities without performing a complete rewrite or line-by-line edit.

How do I choose an editor?

Match the editor's actual service, experience and subject or genre knowledge to the manuscript. Agree scope, deliverables, timetable, fee, confidentiality and revision expectations in writing.

Protect the work and understand the agreement

Copyright, ISBN, Contracts & Money

Open the Rights & Contract Guide →
Do I own copyright in my manuscript?

In many jurisdictions, copyright arises automatically when an original work is created and recorded in a fixed form. Registration rules and evidentiary advantages vary by country.

Does an ISBN protect my copyright?

No. An ISBN identifies a particular publication or edition in the book trade. It does not create copyright ownership or prove literary quality.

Does every format need a different ISBN?

Different product forms normally require separate ISBNs. A paperback, hardback and separately issued ebook are distinct editions or formats in bibliographic systems.

What rights does a publisher need?

Only the rights necessary for the agreed publishing programme. The contract should specify formats, languages, territories, duration, exclusivity and any subsidiary rights.

What is a publishing licence?

A licence permits the publisher to exploit specified rights while copyright ownership may remain with the author. The scope and duration come from the contract.

What is a royalty?

A royalty is the author's contractual share of qualifying revenue from the exploitation of the work. The percentage is meaningful only when the royalty base and deductions are defined.

What does 10% royalty mean?

Ask '10% of what?' It might mean 10% of the retail price, net receipts or another defined amount. Those bases can produce very different payments.

What are net receipts?

Net receipts usually means money actually received by the publisher after deductions permitted by the contract. The definition must be read carefully because contracts differ.

What is an advance?

An advance is money paid against future royalties. Additional royalty payments generally begin after the advance has earned out under the contract's accounting rules.

Do I repay an advance if the book sells poorly?

A conventional advance is usually not repaid merely because sales are weak, but contracts can require repayment in circumstances such as author breach or failure to deliver. Read the actual agreement.

What is rights reversion?

Rights reversion is the contractual return of licensed rights to the author after defined events such as expiry, non-publication, breach or the work becoming unavailable under the contract's test.

What should I check before signing a publishing contract?

Check the rights grant, territory, formats, language, term, publication obligation, royalties, deductions, accounting, warranties, author copies, termination, reversion, assignment and dispute provisions.

Turn approved text into a finished publication

Book Production

Open the Book Production Guide →
What happens after editing is complete?

The text is frozen for production, interior design and typesetting begin, the cover is finalised, metadata and identifiers are checked, proofs are reviewed and print or digital files are approved.

What is typesetting?

Typesetting arranges the edited text into finished pages using a defined trim size, margins, typography, chapter hierarchy, running elements and page architecture.

What is trim size?

Trim size is the final physical width and height of the printed book after cutting. It affects page count, spine width, cover dimensions and reader experience.

What is bleed?

Bleed is image or colour that extends beyond the final trim edge so cutting does not leave unintended white borders.

What does GSM mean in book paper?

GSM means grams per square metre and describes paper weight. It does not by itself tell you opacity, bulk, colour or suitability for a particular book.

What is a print-ready PDF?

A print-ready PDF is the approved production file prepared to the printer's technical requirements for size, fonts, images, colour, bleed and other specifications.

Why is a proof copy important?

A proof allows the publisher and author to inspect layout, page sequence, images, cover, binding and other physical details before the full print run.

What is text freeze?

Text freeze is the point at which the edited manuscript is treated as final for layout. Late rewriting after typesetting can cause pagination changes, errors, delay and extra cost.

Make the book commercially available

Pricing, Distribution & Selling Books

Explore Selling Books →
How should a book be priced?

Price should reflect production economics, format, market expectations, trade discounts, taxes where relevant, royalty structure and the reader's perception of value.

What is book distribution?

Distribution is the system that makes books available to retailers, wholesalers, libraries, institutions and other sales channels. It is not the same as marketing.

Does being listed by a distributor mean bookstores will stock my book?

No. Availability means a bookseller can potentially order the book. Physical stocking remains a separate commercial decision influenced by demand, terms, returns, price and retailer judgment.

What is a wholesaler?

A wholesaler buys or makes books available in bulk to retailers and institutions. It generally sits between publisher/distributor and bookseller rather than marketing the title directly to readers.

What trade discount do bookstores expect?

There is no single universal rate. Discounts vary by territory, channel, distributor, returnability, account size and commercial arrangement.

What are book returns?

Returns are unsold copies sent back under agreed trade terms. Returnability can encourage stocking but creates inventory and financial risk for the publisher.

How do I get a book into bookstores?

Ensure professional metadata, appropriate pricing, supply capability and trade terms, then approach distributors, wholesalers and relevant booksellers with a clear commercial case for the title.

How do I get a book into libraries?

Provide accurate catalogue information and a reliable acquisition route, then identify libraries for which the subject, author, locality or readership is relevant. Institutional buying is selective.

What is print-on-demand?

Print-on-demand produces copies as orders arise rather than holding a large preprinted inventory. It reduces stock risk but can have different unit economics and trade limitations.

How many copies should I print?

Print enough to meet reasonably evidenced demand and channel requirements without creating avoidable inventory. Compare unit cost savings against storage, cash tied up and risk of unsold stock.

Help the right reader discover the book

Marketing, Publicity & Reviews

Open Marketing & Distribution →
When should book marketing begin?

Before publication. Positioning, metadata, cover, description, retailer setup, advance copies and outreach often need to be prepared well before launch.

What is the difference between marketing and distribution?

Distribution makes the book available through sales channels. Marketing creates awareness, relevance and demand. A book can be well marketed but hard to buy, or widely available but poorly discovered.

What is the difference between publicity and advertising?

Advertising is paid placement controlled by the advertiser. Publicity is editorial, media or public attention earned through relevance, interest and professional outreach.

Does social media sell books?

It can help, but follower numbers do not guarantee sales. Relevance, trust, book positioning, availability and repeated reader discovery matter more than raw audience size.

Do I need an author website?

Not compulsory, but useful. A stable author site can hold books, biography, media information, events, contact routes and material that social platforms do not control.

How do I get book reviews?

Identify suitable reviewers, provide accurate information and a legitimate review copy, approach professionally and respect the reviewer's independence. A review is not a purchased promise of praise.

Should I pay for reviews?

Paid or sponsored coverage must be transparently disclosed and must comply with the relevant platform and legal rules. Payment should never be disguised as independent editorial opinion.

What should be in a media kit?

Typically a concise biography, author photograph, cover image, book description, publication information, selected talking points, contact details and any authorised extracts or press material.

What makes a good book launch?

A launch works best when it creates meaningful reader contact, conversation and availability rather than existing only as a ceremony. Ensure books can actually be bought when attention arrives.

How long should I market a book?

As long as it remains available and relevant. Campaign intensity changes, but backlist titles can be revived through anniversaries, themes, new media, events, reviews and rights opportunities.

Build beyond one publication

Author Career

Explore the Author Journey →
When can I call myself an author?

Authorship comes from doing the work of writing and completing serious literary projects, not from follower counts or a particular publishing route.

What is an author platform?

An author platform is the audience, authority, reputation and communication network through which a writer reaches readers. It can include professional expertise, communities, media, events, email and social channels.

Do debut authors need a large following?

Not necessarily. Platform matters more in some nonfiction and commercial contexts than in others. A strong manuscript and clear readership remain fundamental.

What should an author biography include?

Relevant publications, professional background, subject expertise, awards or other information that helps readers and publishing professionals understand the writer in relation to the book.

How should authors use LinkedIn?

Use it where professional identity, subject expertise, publishing news, essays, institutional networks or business readership matter. Avoid treating every post as a sales advertisement.

Should an author write another book immediately?

A sustainable career usually requires continued writing, but the right timing depends on the project, contract, marketing demands and creative readiness.

How important are festivals and speaking events?

They can build readership, professional relationships and authority when the event and audience genuinely fit the author and book.

What is a backlist?

A backlist is the publisher's catalogue of books from earlier seasons that remain available. Strong author careers often depend on keeping older titles discoverable while new books appear.

Find places to submit, learn and participate

Opportunities, Submissions & Literary Life

Enter the Literary Network →
Where can I find writing competitions?

Use a directory that states deadlines, eligibility, fees, prizes and official organiser links. Always recheck the live rules before submitting or paying.

Where can I find writing residencies?

Compare open dates, eligibility, residency costs, funding, application fees, travel, stipend and what you still have to pay. 'Fully funded' does not automatically mean every expense is covered.

Where can I find grants and fellowships?

Search by applicant type, territory, career stage and purpose. Some programmes fund writers directly, while others fund publishers, translators or defined projects.

Where can I submit short stories or poetry?

Research literary magazines and journals that publish your form and are currently accepting submissions. Read rights, simultaneous-submission and payment terms before sending work.

Where can I find translation opportunities?

Look for programmes that clearly state whether the applicant should be the translator, publisher, agent or rights holder and whether the support covers samples, full translation, travel or development.

How do I keep up with publishing news and opportunities?

Use current, dated resources rather than static lists. TGEP's Literary World and Publishing Today separate live developments from evergreen publishing guidance.

For people running books as projects and businesses

Publisher's Desk

Open Publishing Tools →
How should a publisher assess a manuscript?

Separate literary quality from publication fit. Review concept, structure, writing, readership, comparable titles, author position, rights, production demands, sales potential and the publisher's capacity to execute the project.

What is a publishing P&L?

A publishing profit-and-loss forecast estimates revenue and cost for a title or edition. It normally models price, sales volume, discounts, print cost, royalties, freight, marketing and other direct expenses.

How should a publisher decide the first print run?

Use realistic channel commitments, preorder evidence, comparable-title behaviour, unit economics and replenishment speed. A lower unit cost is not a saving if unsold inventory absorbs cash and storage.

What metadata must a publisher control?

At minimum: title, subtitle, contributors, ISBN, format, price, publication date, language, description, categories, keywords, edition and territorial information. Consistency across systems is essential.

How should royalty statements work?

Statements should follow the contract and show the relevant sales, returns, royalty basis, rates, deductions, prior balance, payments and amount due clearly enough for the author to understand the calculation.

How should a publisher manage vendors?

Use written briefs, quotations, specifications, delivery dates, acceptance criteria and approval records for editors, designers, typesetters, printers, distributors and other specialists.

What should a production schedule include?

Editorial completion, text freeze, cover, typesetting, proof rounds, metadata, printer files, print approval, manufacturing, delivery, distribution setup, publication and launch dependencies.

What is the difference between sell-in and sell-through?

Sell-in is stock placed into the trade or retailer channel. Sell-through is stock actually bought by end customers. Publishers should not confuse shipment to a retailer with final consumer demand.

How should rights be tracked?

Maintain a rights record by work, format, language, territory, term, licensee, status, revenue share and expiry/reversion date. Rights management should not depend on memory or scattered email.

What should a publisher monitor after publication?

Availability, metadata accuracy, retailer listings, sales, returns, receivables, publicity, reviews, author activity, stock, rights opportunities and whether the title should receive renewed catalogue attention.

Something has gone wrong

Publishing Problems: What do I do now?

Many people search for publishing information only after a problem has appeared. Start with the practical issue.

My publisher is not paying royalties

Check the agreement, royalty period, statement requirements, payment threshold and amounts actually due. Ask for the contractual statement and payment record in writing. If the issue persists, obtain appropriate professional advice.

My publisher has stopped replying

Keep a written chronology, check formal notice provisions in the agreement and use the publisher's official correspondence address. Silence does not by itself terminate the contract.

My book is not selling

Separate discoverability, availability, positioning, price and product quality. Confirm retailer stock, metadata, cover, description and audience before simply spending more on promotion.

My book is unavailable in bookstores

Check whether the title is actually supplied through the relevant distributor or wholesaler, whether metadata and price are correct, and whether the retailer can order it on viable trade terms.

My Amazon listing is wrong

Identify whether the error originates in metadata supplied by the publisher/distributor or on the retailer page itself. Correct the authoritative metadata source first where possible.

My ISBN metadata is wrong

Correct the title record through the responsible ISBN or metadata system and ensure distributors and retailers receive consistent updated information. Do not create a new ISBN merely to repair ordinary metadata.

My manuscript keeps being rejected

Review both the manuscript and targeting. Rejection can reflect fit, but repeated similar outcomes may justify a fresh editorial assessment or a more selective submission list.

An agent wants money upfront

Establish exactly what the payment is for and whether the person is acting as an agent, editor or paid consultant. Conventional representation is normally commission-based, so unexplained upfront representation fees deserve scrutiny.

A publisher says I must buy hundreds of copies

Determine the publishing model and whether compulsory purchases are stated before contract. Treat undisclosed purchase obligations as a material commercial term, not a minor detail.

I want my publishing rights back

Read the reversion, out-of-print, breach, expiry and termination provisions. Rights return according to the contract or applicable law, not simply because the author asks.

Someone copied my writing

Preserve evidence of your original work and the allegedly copied material. Copyright disputes are fact-specific and may require legal advice in the relevant jurisdiction.

My printer made a serious mistake

Compare the delivered books with the approved proof, purchase order and print specifications. Document defects immediately and follow the agreed rejection, reprint, credit or remedy process.

My cover is wrong after printing

Determine whether the printed result matches the approved cover proof and printer specification. Responsibility depends on where the error entered the production chain.

My distributor has not paid

Reconcile invoices, sales reports, returns, credit notes and contractual payment dates. Escalate through the distributor's formal accounts process with a precise statement of the outstanding balance.

I received a bad review

Do not argue with ordinary critical opinion. Check whether there is a factual or platform-policy issue, but otherwise treat independent reviews as part of publication rather than something the author controls.

I paid for marketing but nothing happened

Compare the promised deliverables with evidence of what was actually performed. 'Marketing' should be defined as specific activities, outputs, dates and reporting, not as a vague guarantee of sales.

My book's price is too high

Rework the sales economics rather than changing price in isolation. Print cost, retailer/distributor discount, royalty basis, taxes and market expectations all affect a viable price.

I found an error after publication

Assess severity. Digital files and future printings may be correctable quickly, while already distributed stock may require an errata notice, replacement decision or controlled correction in the next printing.

Do not confuse the terms

Publishing comparisons

Short distinctions for decisions that are often blurred together.

Literary Agent vs Publisher

An agent represents the author and seeks suitable publishing deals. A publisher acquires rights and brings the book to market under an agreed publishing arrangement.

Editor vs Proofreader

An editor may change structure, language or correctness depending on the editing stage. A proofreader checks the near-final typeset text for remaining errors.

Traditional vs Hybrid Publishing

Traditional publishing normally places agreed publishing cost and commercial risk on the publisher. Hybrid publishing generally involves author investment alongside publisher services.

Hybrid vs Self-Publishing

A hybrid publisher provides an integrated publishing arrangement under its own model. In self-publishing, the author is the publisher and contracts suppliers directly.

Copyright vs ISBN

Copyright protects original expression and related legal rights. An ISBN identifies a particular book edition or format in the book trade.

Advance vs Royalty

An advance is money paid against future royalties. A royalty is the author's contractual share of qualifying revenue.

Distributor vs Wholesaler

A distributor may represent a publisher commercially and supply multiple channels. A wholesaler primarily makes inventory available to retailers and institutions.

Marketing vs Publicity

Marketing is the broader process of positioning and creating reader demand. Publicity is attention gained through media, editorial interest, events and other earned exposure.

Offset Printing vs Print-on-Demand

Offset printing can reduce unit cost at larger quantities but creates inventory. Print-on-demand reduces stock exposure by producing copies as orders arise.

Paperback vs Hardback

They are different product formats with different manufacturing cost, price, market position and usually separate ISBNs.

Retail-Price Royalty vs Net-Receipts Royalty

Retail-price royalty uses the stated cover price as the base. Net-receipts royalty uses money actually received after contractually permitted deductions.

Developmental Editing vs Line Editing

Developmental editing addresses the book's architecture. Line editing addresses the effectiveness of the prose at sentence and paragraph level.

Working tools

Calculate before you decide

Simple estimators for orientation. Contracts, quotations and actual production data remain controlling.

Royalty Estimator

Estimate a royalty from the agreed royalty base.

Enter the royalty base, percentage and qualifying copies.

Approximate Page Count

A rough planning estimate before professional typesetting.

Actual page count depends on trim size, font, leading, margins and book design.

Publisher Contribution Estimate

Estimate contribution per copy before overhead and other title costs.

This is not profit. It excludes freight, returns, marketing, tax, warehousing, overhead and other costs.
Explore TGEP Publishing Tools & Professional Directory →

If you have a publishing question, begin here.

The purpose of Ask TGEP is simple: a writer, author, editor or publisher should not have to search through a maze before understanding what to do next.